Gluten Free Magic Peanut Butter Middles

I know it’s not right to pick favorites. Each one should be loved for it’s different, individual qualities, right? But, I can’t help it. These cookies, with their creamy peanut buttery middle and yummy chocolate cookie coat are definitely my favorite cookies this week. Next week? Well, it might be something else. But for today, definitely these. :)

I love how these cookies look a little fancy, but are super simple to make. They really are like magic, the shape that they take, and the way the peanut butter is nicely in the middle It reminds me of the mystery around how the caramel gets inside the Caramilk bar. But, this mystery is easily solved. Just follow these directions, and you’ll be set.




  1. Tamara says

    After the above two comments, I feel totally selfish, but, well, it can’t be helped…I’m gonna make these and not share…! Thanks for a really fun recipe! T.

    • says

      Haha, that’s funny, Tamara. You don’t have to share. Just put them in the freezer and take out whenever you want a nice little PB & chocolate treat. :)

  2. Melanie says

    These are yummy! Mine came out a little bit dry but it was my fault, I thought the chocolate batter looked too loose to roll around the peanut butter middles. Should have left it as is in the recipe. Super tasty though, I’m sure they will be a hit! Thanks for another great recipe!

  3. says

    I made these yesterday and they turned out amazing!!!! I used the mini chocolate chips by enjoy life and they added a really really yummy flavor. Thanks for sharing and have a very Merry Christmas!!!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *